Skip to main content

The rolling rules toggle explained

When the weekday roll check runs, which puts qualify, the conditions a roll must meet, why a roll did not happen, and why a manual close is not a roll.

Written by Austin Bouley

Rolling rules is an optional toggle on Wheel Paycheck. It is off by default, and on by default if you deployed the Aggressive Growth version. When it is on, the system rolls qualifying puts automatically. You do not roll by closing a position yourself at your brokerage.

What a roll is

A roll buys back your open cash-secured put and sells a new put about 21 days out in one coordinated action, and only when that swap is a net credit (the new put's bid is higher than the cost to close the current one). That is what "rolling" means here.

Closing a put on its own, whether from the Open tab in Self Operating Brokerage or directly at your brokerage, is an exit. It ends that position. It is not a roll, and it does not open a replacement put.

Normally, when a cash-secured put finishes in the money, you get assigned the shares. That is a normal, expected part of the wheel: you bought a stock you approved at a price you chose. With Rolling Rules on, the system tries the automated roll first when the weekday rules below are met, so you can stay in cash and collect another credit instead of taking assignment on that check.

When the roll check runs

The roll check runs every weekday at 3:00 PM Eastern, about an hour before the close. On early-close days it runs at 12:00 PM Eastern. It does not run on market holidays.

Each check looks at open puts that have not been rolled before:

  • On expiration day, a put that is in the money by any amount is considered for a roll.

  • Before expiration day, a put is considered only when it is at least 10% in the money (the strike is at least 10% above the current share price). Otherwise it is held and checked again the next weekday.

When a roll actually happens

All of these must be true. If any one fails, nothing is done: before expiration day the put stays open for the next check, and on expiration day it is left to expire or assign normally.

  • The new put is less likely to be assigned. The replacement is about 21 days out with a delta below 47.

  • The new put pays at least $0.25. Roll replacement puts use the same $0.25 credit floor as new puts.

  • The roll brings in a net credit. The new put's bid must be more than the cost to buy back the current put. If rolling would cost you money, it is not done.

  • This position hasn't been rolled before. Each position gets one roll. A put that was opened by a roll is not rolled again, so the system does not chase a losing trade out in time repeatedly.

Covered calls are not rolled

This setting applies to Wheel Paycheck cash-secured puts only. If you're holding shares and a covered call is going in the money, it is allowed to be assigned and your shares are called away at the strike, which is the profitable end of the wheel, not something to avoid.

Why a roll didn't happen

Submitted rolls, and rolls that fail partway, appear in your execution history. When a put is checked and does not qualify, the system holds it quietly instead of adding a note every weekday. The usual reasons a put is not rolled:

  • Not far enough in the money before expiration day (under 10%).

  • No qualifying contract at roughly 21 days out under 47 delta.

  • Credit below the $0.25 minimum on the replacement put.

  • Not enough credit: the new put's bid didn't exceed the cost to close the current one.

  • Already rolled once.

  • Quotes were unavailable when the check ran, so the system could not price the close or confirm the put is in the money.

In each case the safe outcome applies: nothing is done, and the put stays open, expires, or assigns as it would have with the setting off.

Rolls and your allocation

A roll replaces a put you already hold, so it opens without the allocation hard-limit check that applies to new cash-secured puts. The replacement put then counts against your allocation like any other open put, and its requirement can differ from the put it replaced.

Should you turn it on?

There's no wrong answer here, because assignment isn't a failure in this strategy.

Leave it off if you're comfortable owning the stocks in your approved list. Getting assigned means buying a name you already approved at a discount you already picked, and the system starts selling covered calls against those shares.

Turn it on if you'd rather stay in cash and keep collecting premium where the numbers support it. You'll take assignment less often, and you'll collect an extra credit on the trades that qualify.

One thing to expect

During a roll there is a brief window where the buy-to-close order and the new put are both working, so your collateral for that symbol can look committed twice for a short time. This resolves as soon as the closing order fills.

If the new put fails to sell, the system cancels the buy-to-close order and keeps the original put so it can settle normally. If the close already filled and cannot be cancelled, execution history says so; check your broker for that symbol.

Changing the setting

Settings save automatically. A change applies at the next weekday roll check. It doesn't affect a roll that has already happened, and turning it off leaves a previously rolled position open as it is.

To exit a put without rolling, use Closing a trade manually, or close it at your brokerage. That ends the position. It does not start a roll.

Did this answer your question?